AREDS vs AREDS 2 comes down to one swap. AREDS 2 is the original AREDS formula with the beta-carotene taken out, and 10 mg of lutein and 2 mg of zeaxanthin put in. Vitamin C, vitamin E, zinc and copper stay at the same doses. The change came from the AREDS2 study, which found more lung cancers among people taking beta-carotene, mostly in former smokers.

AREDS vs AREDS 2 at a glance

AREDS and AREDS 2 formulas: daily amounts
Nutrient AREDS (original) AREDS 2
Vitamin C 500 mg 500 mg
Vitamin E 400 IU 400 IU
Beta-carotene 15 mg None
Lutein None 10 mg
Zeaxanthin None 2 mg
Zinc 80 mg 80 mg
Copper 2 mg 2 mg

Sources: the original AREDS trial report (AREDS Research Group, 2001) and the National Eye Institute (NEI).

One thing that trips people up: US supplement labels now list vitamin E in milligrams rather than international units (IU). For the synthetic form of vitamin E used in these formulas, 400 IU works out at 180 mg, using the US Food and Drug Administration’s conversion factor of 0.45 (FDA). So a label showing 180 mg of vitamin E matches the 400 IU in the studies.

Where the two formulas came from

Both formulas come from large US clinical trials sponsored by the National Eye Institute (NEI).

  • AREDS enrolled 3,640 people aged 55 to 80 and followed them for an average of 6.3 years. It tested high-dose antioxidants (vitamins C and E and beta-carotene), zinc, both together, or a placebo. The results were published in 2001.
  • AREDS2 enrolled 4,203 people aged 50 to 85 between 2006 and 2012, all at risk of their age-related macular degeneration (AMD) progressing to an advanced stage. On top of versions of the original formula, it tested lutein and zeaxanthin, omega-3 fatty acids, both, or a placebo. The main results were published in 2013 (AREDS2 Research Group, 2013).

AREDS2 also tested two changes to the original formula itself: taking the beta-carotene out, and lowering the zinc.

Why beta-carotene came out

In AREDS2, lung cancer was more common among people taking beta-carotene: 23 cases (2.0%), compared with 11 (0.9%) among those who weren’t. Most were in former smokers. The researchers suggested lutein and zeaxanthin as a substitute for beta-carotene in the formula (AREDS2 Research Group, 2013). According to the NEI, about 91% of the people who developed lung cancer were former smokers.

That’s why the advice for smokers is clear-cut:

  • The NEI says the original AREDS formula, with beta-carotene, is not recommended for current or former smokers.
  • The Macular Society advises anyone who smokes or has smoked not to take any supplement containing beta-carotene (Macular Society).

So the headline change from AREDS to AREDS 2 was made for safety. In the study’s main analysis, adding lutein and zeaxanthin didn’t make a statistically significant difference compared with placebo.

What AREDS2 found about omega-3 and zinc

Omega-3. AREDS2 tested 350 mg of DHA plus 650 mg of EPA a day. Adding them made no statistically significant difference to the study’s main outcome, progression to advanced AMD, so omega-3 wasn’t added to the formula.

Zinc. AREDS2 compared a lower zinc dose of 25 mg with the original 80 mg. The NEI says the investigators did not find a difference between the two. The standard AREDS 2 formula still contains 80 mg.

That matters in the UK, because the NHS advises not taking more than 25 mg of zinc from supplements a day unless a doctor advises it. It explains that high doses of zinc reduce how much copper the body can absorb, which can lead to anaemia and weakening of the bones (NHS). According to the NEI, copper is in both formulas because high-dose zinc can cause copper deficiency. The Macular Society lists the AREDS2 formula with 25 mg of zinc. That lower-zinc version is worth asking an optometrist or pharmacist about.

Who the formulas are for

This is the part to get right. The NEI says these supplements cannot prevent AMD, and that the trials showed no benefit for people with early AMD or without AMD. It advises talking to a doctor or eye care professional about whether a supplement is appropriate. The Macular Society notes that AREDS2 supplements aren’t available on NHS prescription.

So the formula isn’t a general “eye health” supplement to take just in case. Whether it’s right for someone is a question for their optometrist or eye specialist, who can look at their eyes and their other medicines. The NEI and the Macular Society both flag that vitamin E can interact with blood thinners.

Where PreserVision AREDS 2 fits

The US label for PreserVision AREDS 2 by Bausch + Lomb lists, per daily dose of two soft gels: 500 mg vitamin C, 180 mg vitamin E, 80 mg zinc, 2 mg copper, 10 mg lutein and 2 mg zeaxanthin. It contains no beta-carotene (US National Institutes of Health, Dietary Supplement Label Database). Those are the AREDS 2 amounts in the table above, with vitamin E shown in milligrams.

If you’re buying it for a parent or grandparent, our guide to AREDS 2 for your mum, dad or grandparent covers pack sizes, the zinc note and booking their free NHS eye test. Questions about an order go to our help page.

When to see someone

When to see someone. If sight suddenly gets worse, a dark “curtain” or shadow moves across your vision, or your eye is red and painful, get an urgent optician appointment or contact NHS 111. Call 999 or go to A&E for a red eye with any change in sight, pain when looking at light, a severe headache with feeling sick, or after an eye injury. See an optician if straight lines start to look wavy or crooked, or if you’re worried about your sight. Speak to an optometrist, GP or pharmacist before starting any high-dose supplement, especially if you take other medicines.

Questions

What’s the difference between AREDS and AREDS 2?

AREDS 2 replaces the 15 mg of beta-carotene in the original AREDS formula with 10 mg of lutein and 2 mg of zeaxanthin. Vitamin C (500 mg), vitamin E (400 IU), zinc (80 mg) and copper (2 mg) are the same in both.

Is AREDS 2 better than the original AREDS?

The main reason for the change was safety. Beta-carotene was linked to more lung cancers in the AREDS2 study, mostly in former smokers. In the study’s main analysis, adding lutein and zeaxanthin didn’t make a statistically significant difference compared with placebo. Which formula, if any, suits someone is a question for their optometrist.

Why was beta-carotene removed from AREDS?

In AREDS2, lung cancer was more common in people taking beta-carotene (2.0% against 0.9%), and most of those cases were in former smokers. The researchers suggested lutein and zeaxanthin as a substitute.

Can smokers take AREDS 2?

AREDS 2 contains no beta-carotene, which is the ingredient linked to lung cancer in former smokers. The NEI says the original AREDS formula isn’t recommended for current or former smokers, and the Macular Society says anyone who smokes or has smoked shouldn’t take a supplement containing beta-carotene. Anyone who smokes should check with their GP or optometrist before starting any supplement, and can get help to stop from their GP.

Why does AREDS 2 have so much zinc?

The 80 mg dose comes from the original AREDS trial. AREDS2 tested 25 mg and, according to the NEI, didn’t find a difference. The NHS advises no more than 25 mg of zinc from supplements a day unless a doctor advises it, so ask an optometrist, GP or pharmacist whether the 80 mg version is right.

Sources

All sources accessed 4 November 2026.

This guide is general information, not medical advice. Always read the label and leaflet. For anything about your own eyes, ask a pharmacist, an optician or your GP. If you have eye pain, a sudden change in your sight or an eye injury, call NHS 111, or 999 in an emergency.